}
An amount of ₹20,000 crore is being spent on the Central Vista project this year during the COVID-19 pandemic
Funds have been diverted from public healthcare and COVID-19 response to the Central Vista Project
Why is New Parliament Building being constructed, while the existing Parliament building could have been renovated.
The Central Vista project is contributing to environmental damage, along with reduction of green spaces in the area.
Environmental sustainability is at the core of the Central Vista project, with a comprehensive plan to use centralised systems and infrastructure, promote the use of public transport and have upgradeable technology, systems and services.
All construction and demolition waste received from dismantling of existing building shall be processed in C&D waste treatment plant and recycled for use in construction. Detailed demolition plan along with mitigation measures was submitted to MoEF&CC and Expert Appraisal Committee (Infra-2) after detailed deliberation have recommended for grant of EC. Environmental Clearance has also been granted by MoEF&CC.
The Central Vista Project is leading to a destruction of its Architectural Heritage
While the three heritage buildings retain their architectural majesty, they are under severe stress and in need of comprehensive upgradation. The National Museum, The National Archives of India and the Indira Gandhi National Centre for Arts deserve purpose-designed and well-equipped facilities to showcase the rich cultural history and aspirations of the country.
Detailed Interventions being planned under the project to ensure architectural heritage of the 3 buildings has been provided below.
National MuseumThe National Museum will be relocated to the North and South Blocks, reconceptualized to present the rich heritage and achievements of the nation in a modern and engaging manner. At present, the North and South Blocks house the most important ministries of the Government of India, while being subject to several additions and modifications over the years for technological and service upgrades. After their present functions are relocated to the new Central Secretariat buildings, these Grade-I heritage buildings will be appropriately retrofitted and refurbished to serve as the National Museum. The seamless transition of the National Museum to the North and South Block complex shall be as follows:
The National Archives of India is the largest archival repository in South Asia, housing millions of documents of immense value to our national heritage. The archives were first housed in a building designed by Lutyens, which was completed in 1926. The space has subsequently been extended to add space and modified to add services. However, the present set of buildings do not have the facilities or infrastructure that are essential for an institute that is the custodian of our national heritage. The rooms in existing complex lack proper temperature and moisture control, threatening the preservation of volumes of invaluable documents. Almost all the essential facilities and services required for an archive have become outdated or dysfunctional. Further, the current arrangement of spaces is not conducive to effective, efficient, and safe processing and protection of documents.
In order to address these challenges, while supporting the goals of the institution, a new purpose-designed facility will be built alongside the present historic building. Unlike the contrary perception, the existing heritage building will not be damaged and the existing complex will be appropriately retrofitted and refurbished, while continue to serve the National Archives of India. All documents, manuscripts and artefacts currently housed in the NAI buildings will be itemised and relocated to the new building.
The Indira Gandhi National Centre for ArtsThe Indira Gandhi National Centre for the Arts (IGNCA) is a premier arts centre and an autonomous institute under the Ministry of Culture. The building that currently houses the institution was originally designed as the IGNCA library. All of the institute’s departments are shoehorned into this building. Not being designed for the purpose, the spaces are not adequate for the varied requirements of each department. The present building needs modern infrastructure and better service integration including improved facilities for labs, archival rooms, special storage for archival material, documents, manuscripts, valuable art, etc.
The new building for Indira Gandhi National Centre for Arts is expected to be completed by 2023. The following interventions have been planned as a part of the Central Vista project:
The documents, artefacts and collections from the IGNCA have been catalogued and carefully relocated to the Janpath Hotel, as a secure temporary holding facility. Janpath Hotel will continue to function as the temporary home for IGNCA till the new building is complete, opposite Hyderabad House. Then, these collections will be carefully relocated to upgraded, purpose-built facilities in the new IGNCA building.
Central Vista AvenueThe historic lamp posts and chains are integral and important part of the built heritage of the Central Vista Avenue and will continue to remain so. They have been carefully removed, temporarily, and put in a secure storage facility so that they are not damaged by the ongoing construction work on site. Once the construction work is complete, they will be reinstalled along Rajpath.
Circumvention of procedures has been prevalent during the Central Vista project approval process
The planning and implementation of the Central Vista project has been following all the relevant procedures, required at every stage of the project. Some of the key steps undertaken, have been provided below.
Process followed for selection of architectural consultants for the projectThe project has been taken up after obtaining all statutory and local body approvals following due processes, inviting public objections, wherever required as per law/byelaws. This is in no way done by circumventing existing laws, rules or procedures, which has stood the scrutiny of the Supreme Court of India. However, certain myths have emerged about the entire process, which has been clarified on a point-by-point basis below.
It has been allegedly said that the NDMC role as local body to approve the building plan was deliberately eliminated and role assigned to CPWD based on old Colonial Act.
Breaking up of project in various micro project for ensuring quick approval of projects
Approval of buildings plans from Chief Architect, CPWD (functioning as local body), DUAC, CVC, HCC, AAI, Delhi Fire Services etc. is to be taken for specific buildings based on detailed plans. It is never taken for any Master Plan. Similarly, the Environmental Clearance from MoEF&CC is also can be taken after plans are finalized to the extent that its impact on environment could be assessed reasonably. Environmental Clearance is not required for any Master Plan to be implemented in long period. EC for Parliament Building was applied and granted on recommendation of EAC after deliberations in 2 meeting, considering all objections, response of project proponents. This has withstood scrutiny by Hon’ble Supreme Court and upheld in judgement dated 05.01.2021.
Further, the revised application for environmental clearance of construction of Common Central Secretariat buildings made on 11.12.2020, which had included all the other building components including Parliament for assessing the impact on environment due to this project. Detailed Environment Impact Assessment has been carried out for all the 10 Buildings of Common Central Secretariat, Common Conferencing facility, PMR, PMO and VPR. The impact of already approved New Parliament Building as well as proposed Executive Enclave buildings (whose planning is under way) were also taken into account. This Environment Assessment Report has been submitted to Expert Appraisal Committee of Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India which is in the public domain. The xpert Appraisal Committee which is an independent body of field experts has examined this and recommended for clearance on 2/5/2021. Environmental Clearance has been granted by MoEF&CC on 31.05.2021. Therefore, these statements that piecemeal approach has been taken to surmise adverse impact of this project is unfound and totally false.
OPAAS adopted by DUAC dilutes the scrutiny process
This is other way round, the online system adopted by DUAC and HCC is most transparent system and it ensures that all drawings are uploaded on the system, the proposals are scrutinised in time bound manner and observations are conveyed in transparent manner and these are available in public domain. Hard copies of drawings are invariably submitted by all project proponents and these are also available in record along with soft copies submitted online. This has been done as a part of Ease of Doing Business in Construction Permits and has given substantial relief to the building proponents/ architects to avoid physical meetings and harassment. It has brought transparency, speed and accountability. Approvals under Central Vista Project uses this facility which has been created 3 years back.
Central Vista project will lead to reduction of public spaces and conversion of public spaces into Government use
Why ₹ 13,450 crore is being incurred on new house for Prime Minister
There has been lack of public disclosure on the project
Public consultation is a key part of any project and the processes for such consultation have been laid down in the respective statutes. Prescribed public consultation requirements have been scrupulously observed for all approvals.
The project is continuing during second wave of COVID-19 pandemic by invoking Essential Services Act
The project is a significant drain on resources